Victor Grandy’s art has been shown around the country, but the terms of his federal supervision limit his freedom to travel to his own shows. On November 12, the Ninth Circuit reversed the denial of his request to end that supervision early. The appeals court sent the case back to the same district judge. Its ruling did not end Grandy’s supervision.
The district court had treated 76.5 percent as the share of drug trafficking offenders rearrested before their imposed supervision terms ran out. But Figure C-10 of the U.S. Sentencing Commission’s 2022 report starts with a narrower group: federal marijuana trafficking offenders in the 2010 cohort who had been sentenced to supervision. Over eight years, 46.7 percent were rearrested. The 76.5 percent figure is the share of those rearrested whose rearrest came before the end of the term originally imposed. The commission used that end date as a proxy because it did not know whether they were actually under supervision at rearrest.
Grandy was convicted of distributing crack cocaine. The appeals panel found that the marijuana statistic did not speak to his risk and that the trial judge had relied on the misread figure in finding a significant need to deter him from future crimes. The panel also found that the judge used outdated guidance for probation officers and wrongly counted Grandy’s success under supervision as a reason to keep him under it.
The case turns on two different decisions. When Grandy was sentenced, the drug statute required a ten-year term of supervised release. The Ninth Circuit held that this requirement did not take away the judge’s power to shorten the term later. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(e)(1), a judge can end supervision after one year if the person’s conduct and the interests of justice warrant it, after considering the relevant statutory factors. The government conceded on appeal that the minimum term did not bar early termination, but defended the district court’s weighing of those factors.
Grandy began supervision in May 2019 and was about seven and a half years into the term when the panel ruled. The opinion urged the parties and district court to move quickly so any relief could still matter. It declined to assign a new judge, leaving the same judge to weigh the request again under the standards the panel set out.