Skip to stories
America & the World Independent news
Law & Regulation Colorado

Colorado appeals court orders wildlife rules set aside over 191 online comments

Colorado Parks and Wildlife invited feedback through EngageCPW, but the commission did not consider those submissions before adopting the 2023 rules.

The entrance sign for Summit Reservoir State Wildlife Area in Montezuma County, Colorado, in June 2025. · Jeffrey Beall / CC BY 4.0
The entrance sign for Summit Reservoir State Wildlife Area in Montezuma County, Colorado, in June 2025. · Jeffrey Beall / CC BY 4.0

Coloradans had two ways to send written feedback on proposed wildlife-area rules in 2023. The formal notices listed an email address. Colorado Parks and Wildlife sent readers to its EngageCPW website and told them the commission would consider their comments. The two routes produced very different records. On November 19, the Colorado Court of Appeals reversed the ruling that upheld the rules and directed the district court to vacate them.

The agency received 198 written comments. All seven emails went into the official record. None of the 191 EngageCPW submissions did, and the commission did not consider them. Division staff prepared a two-and-a-half-page memo summarizing portions of the online feedback. The appeals court found the agency fell short of the Colorado Administrative Procedure Act, which required it to include and consider the written comments it had invited through the site. Read the court’s findings on the submissions and the record.

The rules concerned what visitors could do on state wildlife lands and waters. They restricted activities including recreational camping and launching vessels for uses other than hunting or fishing, with rules and exceptions for individual properties. The appeals panel resolved the case on the public-comment issue and left the plaintiffs’ separate challenge to the rules’ treatment of hunting and fishing undecided. Colorado Parks and Wildlife told Colorado Public Radio it was reviewing the decision and weighing next steps. Read the opinion.

The opinion sends the case back to the district court to vacate the challenged rules. It sets no new access schedule for individual properties. Visitors planning a trip can use the state’s wildlife area finder to check entry requirements and look up rules for their destination.

Cover photo by Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0. Resized for publication and cropped in previews.

This post is available in the following languages:

Link