A federal appeals court told a Virginia district court to narrow a demand for 18 months of journalists’ LinkedIn records. It also sent back a separate order that restricts whom LinkedIn can tell about the demand. The two decisions are linked. If the company can show the records order to one vetted lawyer for the news outlet, that lawyer could help the court identify which records concern unrelated reporting. Fourth Circuit opinion, pp. 3–5 and 21–22
The Nov. 10 ruling came in an investigation into a leak of classified information. The records order covers metadata, including who contacted whom on LinkedIn and when. That can expose a confidential source’s identity even when investigators are seeking only the records about a message. The judges said many contacts appeared unrelated to the leak inquiry. Fourth Circuit opinion, pp. 3–5
Under the Stored Communications Act, the government needs specific facts giving the court reasonable grounds to believe the records it seeks are relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation. The panel recognized that investigators cannot know in advance which records will matter. It directed the district court to weigh the government’s need and whether the request can be divided into narrower categories. If the government cannot justify sweeping in a category that appears to have little connection to the inquiry, the judge must narrow the order. Fourth Circuit opinion, pp. 11–14 and 18–19
The other order imposed a one-year secrecy restriction with an exception for legal counsel. LinkedIn proposed telling a single lawyer for the news outlet who had previously been vetted by the government. The panel said the district court must adopt that exception unless the government offers a more persuasive explanation of how it could compromise the investigation. The judge would still decide how much data LinkedIn must hand over. Fourth Circuit opinion, pp. 19–22
The panel declined to throw out either order entirely. It also upheld the denial of LinkedIn’s request for access to the government’s confidential submissions to the judge. The next decisions belong to the district court in Newport News, where the government can defend the scope of the demand and explain any risk of letting the newsroom lawyer see it. Fourth Circuit opinion, pp. 1, 2–3 and 22–24