Skip to stories
America & the World Independent news
Law & Regulation Maryland

Fourth Circuit upholds denial of Kalshi’s bid to block Maryland enforcement

Two judges agreed to leave the denial of temporary relief in place. They took different routes through federal commodities law.

A postcard postmarked in 1911 shows the Richmond building that now houses the Fourth Circuit. · Virginia Commonwealth University Libraries
A postcard postmarked in 1911 shows the Richmond building that now houses the Fourth Circuit. · Virginia Commonwealth University Libraries

A divided federal appeals court, in an opinion dated November 18, left in place a Maryland judge’s refusal to temporarily block state sports wagering enforcement against Kalshi. The Fourth Circuit’s 2–1 decision concerns Kalshi’s sports event contracts and the preliminary injunction it sought while the case proceeds.

Maryland gaming regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025, taking the position that its sports contracts required a state sports wagering license. Kalshi argued that the contracts are swaps traded on a federally regulated exchange and fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive authority. The district court denied temporary relief in August 2025, finding that Kalshi was unlikely to succeed on its claim that federal law displaced Maryland’s rules.

The appeals panel’s shared ruling affirmed that result in one sentence. Judge Roger Gregory assumed for the sake of argument that the contracts could be swaps. Even on that assumption, he concluded that Kalshi had failed to show that federal law displaced Maryland’s authority. Judge Stephanie Thacker took a different route: in her view, a contract that pays based on who wins a game does not pay based on whether the game takes place, so the contracts fail a threshold part of the statutory definition of a swap.

Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. She concluded that the sports contracts qualify as swaps and that federal law displaces Maryland’s rules as applied to them. She would have sent the case back for the district judge to consider the remaining requirements for temporary relief.

The practical result is that the requested injunction remains denied. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown welcomed the ruling, citing consumer protections under state oversight. The ruling resolves Kalshi’s appeal over interim relief. The panel issued no shared ruling on whether the contracts are swaps, and its decision itself sets no date for a change in what Maryland users can trade.

In a November 19 filing, Kalshi asked the appeals court for two more weeks to petition for rehearing, seeking to move the deadline from December 2 to December 16.

This post is available in the following languages:

Link