Skip to stories
America & the World Independent news
Law & Regulation Indiana

Indiana Supreme Court clears Garten to take oath and leaves certification restrictions in place

The November 17 writ lifted the bar on seating the District 45 senator. It left Clark County’s election paperwork under a separate restraint.

The Indiana Statehouse in Indianapolis, where the Senate held Organization Day, in a 2016 archive photo. · Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division (LC-DIG-highsm-40974)
The Indiana Statehouse in Indianapolis, where the Senate held Organization Day, in a 2016 archive photo. · Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division (LC-DIG-highsm-40974)

The Indiana Supreme Court cleared Republican Chris Garten to take his seat in the state Senate on November 17, before the chamber was set to swear in members. The unanimous emergency writ removed one provision of a Clark Circuit Court order. The provisions blocking county officials from certifying two races and forwarding the Senate vote statement stayed in place under that ruling.

The November 16 restraining order put those restrictions in separate paragraphs. Paragraph 1 barred Clark County election officials from certifying the November 3 results for Senate District 45 and county auditor. It also barred them from sending a certified statement of the county’s District 45 votes. Paragraph 2 barred Garten from taking the oath or being seated. The state Supreme Court directed the trial court to vacate only the second paragraph.

In clearing Garten to take his seat, the justices cited the Indiana Constitution’s rule that each chamber judges the elections of its own members. The Senate Republican caucus said Garten was sworn in as Senate president pro tempore on Organization Day, with Chief Justice Loretta Rush administering that oath. The emergency writ did not decide whether the disputed election results were accurate.

The trial court order set a November 18 hearing at 1:15 p.m. local time on the request for a preliminary injunction. In the separate writ proceeding, the Supreme Court gave respondents until December 7 to respond and submit any supplemental record. It left Garten’s remaining requests under consideration and expressly allowed the trial court proceedings to continue.

This post is available in the following languages:

Link