New Jersey has asked a federal judge to give homeland security officials seven days to tell state investigators and The GEO Group whether the company may comply with a subpoena for records from Delaney Hall, the immigration detention center GEO operates in Newark. The Nov. 17 complaint asks for a decision on disclosure. The requested deadline would allow federal officials to answer yes or no.
The records would help investigators examine how people held at Delaney Hall are screened and treated. The state’s account of the subpoena says it seeks detainees’ medical records, the facility’s health care and intake screening policies, medical providers’ qualifications and licenses, plans for limiting communicable disease and documentation of staff use of force. GEO’s facility page identifies U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement as the facility’s exclusive user and lists access to medical care among the services GEO provides.
The dispute follows two routes laid out in the same August 7 letter. New Jersey directed its subpoena to GEO and gave the company until August 21 to respond. The state also submitted an alternative request under federal disclosure procedures in case GEO invoked them. According to the complaint’s account of GEO’s letters, the company classified the requested material as federal records, invoked Department of Homeland Security rules and indicated it had followed the procedure for sending the request to the department. New Jersey disputes that a private contractor needs federal permission to answer the state subpoena.
State officials say they sent the department a copy of the subpoena on September 29 and followed up on October 20. The complaint says they had received no response from federal defendants when they filed suit in Washington, D.C. In a statement reported by PIX11, a DHS spokesperson said ICE is regularly audited and inspected, that Delaney Hall complies with applicable state and local laws and that detainees receive medical treatment.
The complaint invokes the Administrative Procedure Act and asks the court to declare that the federal defendants unlawfully withheld and unreasonably delayed a response. Its request for relief asks for notice of the federal decision within seven days. Even if the court grants that request, investigators could still face a separate dispute over access to the records if federal officials decline to authorize their release.