Two shoppers can pay different prices for the same item under a bill the New York City Council passed Thursday. What matters is how the seller arrived at the price. A publicly advertised flash sale could still go ahead. An algorithm that uses personal data to show different shoppers different prices for the same item would run into the bill’s ban, unless an exception applies. The Council passed Intro. 891-A 44–5 on November 12.
The distinction is easiest to see with a loyalty program. Under the bill, a store could offer a genuine discount through a program shoppers knowingly join, provided the offer is clearly disclosed to members under the applicable rules. A program could even use a customer’s purchase history to determine a disclosed discount tier, as long as it does not combine that history with other personal data apart from program enrollment. A seller could not use that exception to quietly raise the regular price for a particular shopper.
Businesses that offer qualifying personalized discounts would have to maintain a way for shoppers to ask what personal data the business considered and how it used those data to set a particular price. The bill would make violations subject to civil penalties of up to $1,000 each. It also sets out exceptions, including for certain creditworthiness decisions and pricing that state or federal law requires or expressly authorizes.
The Council docket lists the measure at the mayor’s desk and shows no enactment date. The bill gives businesses a year after it becomes law before the rules take effect. For shoppers watching for a start date, the date to look for on the docket is enactment, rather than the date of Thursday’s vote.